Welcome to the forum Jessica! Well, I've heard from a couple folks who had a wedding on a cruise that it was effortless and perfect so it really depends on the size of your group, what you want out of the wedding and how much you want control over decorations/settings, etc... I was pretty indecisive at first as well. We started out thinking we'd do a wedding in the Bahamas cuz... well, cuz it sounded about right. Then we read up on this forum and made a decision based on reviews, pictures, dates available, etc... and it all came together. Don't worry, you'll figure out a perfect setting for you guys here soon. Wow, long winded welcome but we've all been there so wanted to share that bit.