I know LOTS of us DIY our own albums, guestbooks etc and use sites like Shutterfly, Mpix, Blurb, etc.
I just came across this review of about a dozen or MORE different online book publishers...
The guy who wrote it ordered albums from all the companies and then compared them, so it's a REALLY good review of each one, comparing quality etc.
And he even reviews some Canadian sites for all the Canadian BDWers!:-)
Anyway, here's the link to the review:
It's REALLY long (15 pages!) but near the bottom of the first page, there's a link that says "skip to conclusion" and that gets you to the end results...which is probably what you'll be most interested in:-)
Hope this helps all you DIYers :-)