Jump to content


Bridesmaid Picking Advice

  • Please log in to reply
21 replies to this topic

#1 MagsieMexico

  • Jr. Member
  • 420 posts

    Posted 19 January 2007 - 02:24 PM

    I have a group of 5 best girlfriends in California from my 10 years living there.

    I have a group of 5 best girlfriends in London from living here growing up, and again now (moved back 5 months ago).

    I have a sister.

    My fiance has a sister.

    If I had all of those as bridesmaids, I'd have 12 bridesmaids, and that would be half of the people at my destination wedding!!!

    I really like the idea of bridesmaids... for many reasons, and a lot because i am really close to these girls... but I just don't know what to do.

    So maybe just have none??

    What do you ladies think?
    Margaret & Eric

    #2 anaderoux

    • Sr. Member
    • 3,220 posts

      Posted 19 January 2007 - 02:29 PM

      I think if you like bridesmaids you should have BMs, doesn't matter if they're many.. the pics will look gorgeous with you and the girls you love the most, dressed in the same color :)

      #3 Christine

      • VIP Member
      • 21,514 posts
      • Wedding Date:July 20, 2007
      • Wedding Location:Napa, California
      • LocationReno, NV

      Posted 19 January 2007 - 02:31 PM

      I would pick the three you are closest too then and make sure to have the other girls be VIP's and give them special jobs, like a reading, being in charge of something. For example, my sister is not in my wedding, but is a hair stylist and is doing my hair, one of my best friends went to pastry school and is making my cake.
      Christine + Will (married 7/20/07) + Ainsleigh (born 6/25/08) + Nolan (born 11/9/10) + Delaney (born 12/31/13) = One Very Happy Family!

      #4 deleted

      • VIP Member
      • 7,459 posts

        Posted 19 January 2007 - 02:36 PM

        I think I might just do the sisters...then it's not like you are picking favorites among friends. The friends can still be super involved and part of everything...they can just wear whatever dress they want. Honestly, sometimes it's a relief NOT to be asked to be bridesmaid, ya know? Plus I think it makes sense to have a number proportional to your entire wedding. I think that 12 BMs at a 30 person wedding would be a bit much. Just my 2 cents though...when you are the bride you get to do whatever you want!! :)

        #5 LCBride2007


          VIP Member

        • VIP Member
        • 24,768 posts

          Posted 19 January 2007 - 03:29 PM

          i had a similar dilema. i could easily pick 1 girl - i have 1 sister. but if it went beyond that, i'd have trouble - how do i pick out of all the friends? and then there's paul's sisters. so we went with no bridal party. part of me regrets it because i don't get to pick out BM dresses and have a party with them. but the other part of me is relieved i don't have to pick out BM dresses and have a party with them!

          #6 TammyB

          • Sr. Member
          • 10,630 posts

            Posted 19 January 2007 - 03:33 PM

            I like Janet's idea, use just the sisters.

            #7 TammyWright


              Admin & Owner

            • Administrators
            • 11,681 posts
            • Wedding Location:Dreams Los Cabos

            Posted 19 January 2007 - 03:33 PM

            i would just pick the sisters...too many BM's=PITA!

            Founder and Owner of BestDestinationWedding.com  /  Bride & Groom Fly FREE Promotion

            Looking for a travel agency that specializes in Destination Weddings-CLICK HERE?  We are an award winning travel agency and you can read our reviews here.
            Awards and recognition: 
            Palace Resorts Winner "Top Travel Agent", "Top Homebased Travel Agency" PRO Platinum Agency (Top Award)     |    AMResorts Master Agent & Top Agency  
            Karisma Hotels Diamond Level 5 (highest production), Top 10 Azul Weddings, Top Wedding Coordinator | Wright Travel & Karisma GIVC Benefits
            Travel Impressions Best of the Best Globe Winner    |     Apple Vacations Golden Apple Winner  
            sml_gallery_206696_17612_13451.pnggallery_206696_17572_8409.jpg    sml_gallery_206696_17572_1003.jpg
            Vendor rules are HERE! Please read!  If you are a vendor and looking to advertise your business, please email ads@bestdestinationwedding.com.

            #8 JulieG

            • VIP Member
            • 8,323 posts

              Posted 19 January 2007 - 03:53 PM

              If you are close to his sister, then put her in as well. If not, you can just have your sister. I think all of them would be too much. You have to sit down and think about who would be the best people to have. I have some friends who are good friends but are really flaky and I don't think will do the things they need to. I also have friends who are a little self centered and I don't think they would want/do, what is best for me. So, you have to think about that. Or, just use your sis or both if you are close to his sister.

              #9 MagsieMexico

              • Jr. Member
              • 420 posts

                Posted 19 January 2007 - 05:37 PM

                Thanks Ann, I had pretty much decided to do none, exactly for the reasons that all you wise ladies mention, but then I read your post earlier today saying you kind of regretted it!!

                i think I will tell all of my best friends that I want them involved but with such a small wedding, I am only going to have my sister, although I'm closer to them than to my sister in most cases! But I love my sis a tonne too, and it's a different kind of closeness....
                Margaret & Eric

                #10 Nrvsbride

                • Sr. Member
                • 5,248 posts

                  Posted 19 January 2007 - 05:46 PM

                  I have the same problem. If I put all the people I am closest to I will have 12 bridesmaids. It seems like so much especially at a DW. I think ultimately you should have as many bridesmaids as you want. If you pick and choose a couple from each group someone is inevitably going to feel hurt and left out. If you want all 12 then do all 12. If not I would do just your sister and your FSIL. Good luck.


                  0 user(s) are reading this topic

                  0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users