Hi Erin - We just came back from our Key West wedding scouting mission. The Westin is really nice and the people were lovely. We also looked at the Ocean Key which has a pier set-up as well. That was very pretty too. We visited the Hyatt, which was fantastic - they have a private room with amazing views for a reception & a few ceremony sites on the property. The fourth place we looked at was the Pier House, which was wonderful. I know there are lots of other venues as well. Have fun researching & planning!