I think I like the second pair better because I wouldn't want slouchy boots!!
Interestingly enough, I used to hate Uggs because I would always see teenage girls wearing them with mini skirts in the middle of winter...which makes no sense to to me (sorry to those of you who may have done this)!
Then I got tired of my feet getting cold so I caved in and bought a pair last winter, and I love them. I have the Classic version in chesnut so I'm still fairly new to the Ugg community, LOL. My feet are small so I had to order from the big kids section They are just so easy to pull on and off and help to keep your feet warm...I might have to get myself another pair this winter!