Hello!!
CONGRATS!!
I would/did personally pick Jamaica! Why are you debating between those two? I kinda made a list that ruled out places...(ie mexico, cuba, dom rep, etc until i got to jamaica....it basically came down to its a place nmost ppl want to go to, but cant justify b/c its just that bit more then the other places....buts its way cheaper then some of the other islansds....
Hope that helps!!