Jaims - I'm looking into The Lazy Gourmet as well. According to my WC, they are "THE" caterers in Cabo. NO comparison. Also, she told me that they work with ANY budget you have. Even if you told them you only want to spend $25 per person, they can do it. Good luck!
Also, I have a quick question (off the topic) - Are you getting married at the villa? If so, which one? I'm having trouble finding a villa that works with all my criteria, so I'm always up for suggestions. Thanks!