My fiance and I also didn't really want the untucked look or shorts. We're going with pants, vest, dress shirt (rolled sleeves) and a tie. This is our inspiration but we're going with light grey (pants and vest) and a white shirt.
Groom look.jpg 76.91KB
The groomsmen will be in white dress shirts and light grey pants.
Groomsmen look.jpg 24.33KB
We were going to go the custom route but kept finding bad reviews on places we initially liked. I ended up getting a 40% off purchasing from Moores from a Bridal Show and we found a nice light grey option. This also makes it easier as our groomsmen are in different cities.