So I found some fun OOT items on oriental trading today and I think I got a pretty good deal on everything:
I bought the following for our approx. 50 guests:
Flip-Flop Gummy Treats - 50 items
Tropical Fun Pack Candy - 57 items
Wedding Ring Shot Glasses - 60 rings
Plastic Beach Safes for Money - 60 safes
Flip-Flop Playing Cards - 36 (1 per bag)
I got all of this for $100 because there is also a free shipping code: "WSTRM01"