Janis, I just PM'd you.  My fiancé is actually from St. Maarteen and he has family that lives in Anguilla. Last time I visited both islands was well over 8 years ago but the one beach we visited in Anguilla (near Cap Juluca) was exquisite. This whole idea of us having DW is relatively new.  We plan on going to back St. Maarteen within the next few months both to visit with family and to do a preliminary site visit. The only con is that inclusive options aren’t realily available in Anguilla. I know my guests would prefer an inclusive option. So I'm also considering other islands like St. Lucia where all inclusive is the norm.  This whole business of planning a wedding is a tad frustrating, even for this event planner.