omg thank you! I was hoping to find a local! I've looked into both of those caterers and have gotten preliminary quotes, I'll look into the restaurants that you listed as well. For our reception we are doing a 2 hour sunset cruise with Fury, so I need food that is boat-friendly. We'll have approx 30 guests (I hope!). I will definitely take a look at your website, I hadn't come across it in my searches. I'm glad there's another florist option because so far I haven't been super impressed with what I've seen. But like I said it's really hard to judge from websites, which is why I'm glad to get some local opinions!
I think for the hotel we will just go with a big chain that is close to Fury's docking spot for our guests convenience. For our wedding night though we were planning on switching to a smaller B&B that is honeymoon oriented.