both are great locations !! i know that doesn't help. lol but, look at the odds, and ends. good, and bads. maybe that will help. i will get married in dominican in march 2012 in punta cana . the reason my fiance is living there. so i dont have a choice i suppose. lol but, what ever makes you happy. and where your quest will enjoy the most. cause both has wonderful beaches !! any info you want to ask me dont hesitate to write. take care ...