Hi everyone! We're getting married on Siesta Key in April 2012. We are still working out the catering/restaurant situation however. Can anyone recommend a good restaurant right in Siesta Key that they may have worked with before? We're looking at a rehearsal dinner (not necessarily on Siesta Key, but maybe just in the Sarasota area) and then the reception dinner to be right there in Siesta Key. I currently have several calls into a few restaurants (The Cottage and Blu Smoke Island Grill) but communication does not seem to be the number priority. My wedding coordinator tells me both these restaurants are really good despite the communication skills, but if I can't get them to answer me, there's no way to book them.
Any tips anyone can share would be GREATLY appreciated! Thanks in advance!!