Just returned from our trip and I'll start a thread with a recap of our vendors but I have to say, I was very impressed with the ceremony Rev. Ron Lowery, "The Maui Marrying Man" performed. It was exactly what I could have asked for, and more. The white tuberose leis included with the package were gorgeous, and very fragrant! I was worried they might be cheesy or cheap, but they were gorgeous - absolutely perfect for our wedding!
His prices are more than reasonable ($199 for a ceremony without photography, or vow renewal, and $499 for the package which included photography, lei exchange, marriage certificate) and he was extremely flexible given the circumstances that we had transpire (more on that later!!). We used his partner, Dot, for our ceremony photography, plus a shoot after, and I'll post more feedback on her services once we receive our photos.
So, all in all, I would say go with Rev. Ron! He made our wedding day very special and was great to work with!