"Stolen" by Dashboard Confessional. (I posted it earlier in the thread, but this topic is so popular that it's hard to follow each girl's responses.) We went through a punk/emo phase a while ago and went to a couple Dashboard Confessional concerts. "Stolen" is toned down enough to be a little more mainstream (not as whiny as typical emo), and we like the lyrics.
I WOULD have liked to see my family's reactions to "Sexy [Chick]" vows though! I think my MIL would have fainted. She's very home-maker-ish. (I'm snickering again - it never fails!)