I ordered as part of a goodie in our welcome bags! I got the flip flop luggage tag, granted they won't be able to use them on the way down, but at least they'll have it on the way back! These were running around $2.50/piece, but the best price I found was a pack of 12 for $24.99 on target.com. Here's the link:
@lliaPSU - We are trying to decide between handing them out at the resort after we arrive or handing them out before. I really don't want to bring alot down with us but FI wants to hand them out at the resort. Decisions, decisions!!
Is anyone else doing luggage tags? If so, are you ordering them from Vistaprint or just making them yourselves? I really want to do them but not sure where to start.