Help me choose a ring for FI!

[kevsgirl]

UPDATED WITH PICS ON FI's HAND!!! - see end of thread

 

 

I've managed to narrow down the options to 4 rings... they may look similar, but there are differences.

 

Since my ring is yellow gold, FI wants his to be too. He wants something classic and simple, but not too boring. Other than that, he's been difficult in terms of giving me too many ideas. He likes 2 colours and I think 6mm is the best width, but narrow looks good on him too. I know that rounded usually looks better than straight edge too, but it's not necessary. He's not super fond of the brushed look - he prefers very glossy gold, but then again he's not adverse to brushed. Arrgh. Can you tell how difficult it is to get him to decide?

 

Help! I don't want it to be boring, but I also don't want to get something he won't like.

 

A) Rounded step cut: 6mm 14karat yellow gold, high gloss (Item #WB1408 )

 

 

Flat step cut: 6mm 14K yellow gold, high gloss (Item #WB1211Y)

 

 

C) Satin center miligrain: 6mm 14k yellow gold (Item # WB7706)

 

D) Same as 3 but with white gold in centre and yellow outside.

 

[KLC77]

I really like the third one... it has some character to it.

[Yari]

I voted for the third one cause that is the one my FI got but in platnium.

[MelanieS]

I voted for #3, because in a very, very short time #1 and 2 won't look shiny anymore - it doesn't take very much wear to scratch them.

[kevsgirl]

Quote:

Originally Posted by Yari I voted for the third one cause that is the one my FI got but in platnium.

Yari - Great minds think alike Did you buy it online?
Don't suppose you have a pic of FI trying it on?

[Sandra E.]

I like option B.

[Chiquita]

I like A and B best.. hard to decide between them

[nikkianddean]

Quote:

Originally Posted by timelsel I voted for #3, because in a very, very short time #1 and 2 won't look shiny anymore - it doesn't take very much wear to scratch them.

I agree with a woman who knows about what a ring loks like...31 years later

[Alyssa]

#2 definitely!

[stltk]

I like C & D, they've got a lil something different than the others.