Both of you are absolutely wonderful. Thank you for helping. I really liked everything I saw about the Pierhouse until I read about their "top-optional" beach. That made me really nervous that we'd be saying "I do" next to some half naked lady, not exactly how I've been picturing my wedding. I will definitely contact them again then.
Juliepfief, Are you planning on staying at the Pierhouse or could you offer suggestions on places to stay in Key West? I don't really want to spend the days leading up to my wedding around half naked people either. I think I'll just be uncomfortable.
Inanna, the private beach house or estate actually sounds really nice. We would like to have our wedding New Year's Eve and finding somewhere that will carry the reception past 11 or into the New Year has been a pain so far. I will definitely look through everything you suggested. Which estate did you end up using?
Thank you both again!