Like you, I felt doing my own research and piecing together my vendors was the way to go. So in lieu of hiring a full on wedding planner I hired a day-of wedding planner through We'veGotTheKeys. Fiona was awesome and handled EVERYTHING the day-of. They were also able to recommend a couple of my vendors, but honestly Key West is such a small island that I didn't find it that hard to do my own research on the vendors. Personally I didn't want to pay a planner to book my cakes, flowers, etc, b/c there really are only a couple reputable vendors for both of these on the island. I just called them all, talked to them and went with who I felt the most comforable with. Some made it really easy by being rude or unresponsive, in that case I just went with their competitor. I went with Tony Gregory as my photographer b/c a friend of a friend recommended him. He was great to work with and we ended up with over 1,000 shots, handed to us on a cd within 12 hours of the wedding! Then with our purchased package I think he cropped/altered/enhanced 50 of our choice, but we have them all digitally. We had a very unique situation though, a family friend, who is also a wedding photographer announced at the last minute her gift to us was that she was also going to photograph our wedding so we had both of them there! In retrospect it's kind of funny and Tony was a really good sport about it and in the end we actually ended up with some really cool shots from 2 different perspectives.